hi cplcody,
how old is your hdd????whats the company name
?m asking the hdd company not dell and yes dude anyhow if you wish to recover your pics dont accept the new hard drive as they will take the old one away on which you can still recover your data
Just call dell to make sure your old drive is not corrupted simply talk to their hardware department,they will run few tests to make sure your old drive is not corrupt if its corrupt then only exchange with new one else no use